great cloud of witnesses, all right
by bam
early this morning, i opened a package i’d been waiting for all week. it was a great fat book titled, a great cloud of witnesses, and it’s a compendium of saints, so ordained and otherwise. i find myself most drawn to the “otherwise,” the ones whose lives of holiness — a definition worth a lifetime of delving into — the ones whose unheralded kindness, the ones whose courage in the face of attack (be it rubber bullet or tear gas, the lynching tree or one man’s knee), the ones whose words, whose acts of noble defiance, whose everyday living-breathing gospel hold a candle in the darkness.
i’m bringing five of them here to the table this morning, to let their voices be the ones you weave into your day, your soul, your imagination. they are the ones with something wise and beautiful and riveting to say, something worth listening deeply to.
my posture today is one bent low in the sacred prayer of listening.
the ones i’ve gathered here are imani perry, interdisciplinary scholar of race, law, literature, and african-american culture at princeton university; the late great poet and writer james baldwin; michael curry, presiding bishop of the episcopal church; otis moss III, senior pastor of the iconic trinity united church in chicago; and, not least, late-night comedian and cultural critic, trevor noah.
first up, imani perry, with these excerpts from her june 3 essay in the paris review, titled, “a little patch of something,” a meditation that begins with her growing a flat of microgreens on her bedside table, and takes us far far beyond the endosperm of germination. we pick up a couple paragraphs in….(to read the entire essay, click the hyperlink above.)
By any measure of politics and civil order, Black people in the antebellum and Jim Crow South existed in a cruel relationship to land and the agricultural economy. Exploitation happened from birth to death, from the fields all the way to the commissary where people overpaid landowners for minimal goods. Black people gave birth in the cane, died in the cotton, bled into the corn. But out of little patches of something, carefully tended to because beyond survival is love, came reward. The earth gave moments of pleasure: Latching onto a juicy peach—your teeth moving from yellow to red flesh. Digging up a yam, dusting off its dirt, roasting it so long the caramelized sweetness explodes under your tongue. Running your hands across the collard leaves coming up from the ground rippled flowerlike. That green is as pretty as pink.
…But during shelter in place it seems touching and tending to plants has become both more universal and more essential.
Soulful even. I watched my friends and family on screens as they delighted in collards, berries, tomatoes, and chives. Small joys as death rolled by. At first there was a rumor that Black people didn’t get COVID-19, as though by some miracle of our physical constitution. Then we were told it cast us all in the same boat, a virus couldn’t discriminate. Finally, we saw that though a virus doesn’t discriminate the persistent ways a society does had us falling fast. And it seemed we, Black people, all knew someone, or knew someone who knew someone, who died alone in a ward, or a home, or at home. Caresses of loved ones were verboten in the final moments. You had to stay safe from the virus.
This was the context in which the world shifted for the second time in the same season. Police officers killed Breonna Taylor, George Floyd, and more, and more. So many in fact that even if I gave you the whole list I know I would be missing some precious lives that also deserve to be remembered. Being killed by police officers is the same old same old for Black people. Same rage, same sorrow, same politicians’ calls for quiet protest but never remedy. The protests grew like wildfire. People emerged from their homes, hungry to stand with each other, to beat back loneliness and fear, angry, resistant and insistent. From every quarter and dozens of states and nations, people have stepped outside to say:
“Enough!”
The plants are growing too. Their slowly spreading leaves are synchronous with the shattering glass, the rubber bullets, the gouged-out eyes, the tanks and bullhorns. That synchronicity is not new. When the Klan mobs charged into Black homes, ripping out someone who was loved, dragging them in the dirt, dismembering his body bit by bit before stringing him up, the turnips kept growing. When the bombs shook Dynamite Hill in Birmingham, and the hoses knocked over skinny brown children, the pecans fell from branches. Plums hung heavy, purple and sweet as hot rage bubbled from the gut through the vocal passages.
…I’m remembering all that, looking at my little tray of microgreens, sleepless with fear about the devastation just around the corner, yet hopeful too because the dam holding back rage has broken. I want to hold hands with my friends who have been tear-gassed and pepper-sprayed, who I have seen stumbling yet still holding a banner aloft: BLACK LIVES MATTER. The grace of a shared meal seems so remote now. But those days will return sooner than we think. And if this moment of righteous rage turns into a movement that will be sustained, we will need to both fight and nourish each other. We will have to bolster and build more networks to share food and provide care and shelter, not as an alternative to protest but as an essential element of it. It is a lesson we learned over centuries. Freedom dreams are grown and nurtured out of the hardest, barely yielding soul. Our gardens must grow. That is a metaphor and a literal truth. When the bruised and battered seek refuge from the storm, may all of us who believe in freedom remain ready to feed and sustain them.
briefly, we turn to the words of poet-activist james baldwin, spoken back in 1970, when he and anthropologist margaret mead took to a new york city stage for seven and half hours of “brilliance and bravery,” as described by cultural critic maria popova. mead and baldwin’s entire conversation was later published as a book, a rap on race (1971), and is worth pulling from a bookshelf, your own or your library’s.
baldwin’s words, wise to press against our hearts, include this one searing truth: “we’ve got to be as clear-headed about human beings as possible, because we are still each other’s only hope.”
bishop michael curry, the first african-american presiding bishop of the episcopal church, took to the op-ed pages of the washington post last weekend (before the travesty of tear gas and rubber bullets that cleared the way for the president of the united states to walk through lafayette park to the steps of “the presidents’ church,” st. john’s episcopal church, to wield a bible as if a cudgel (by my eyes anyway). bishop curry wrote, in part:
Our nation’s heart breaks right now because we have strayed far from the path of love. Because love does not look like one man’s knee on another man’s neck, crushing the God-given life out of him. This is callous disregard for the life of another human being, shown in the willingness to snuff it out brutally as the unarmed victim pleads for mercy.
Love does not look like the harm being caused by some police or some protesters in our cities. Violence against any person is violence against a child of God, created in God’s image. And that ultimately is violence against God, which is blasphemy — the denial of the God whose love is the root of genuine justice and true human dignity and equality.
Love does not look like the silence and complicity of too many of us, who wish more for tranquility than justice.
next up is otis moss III, senior pastor of trinity united church of christ in chicago. moss is as brilliant a preacher as i’ve heard in a long long while, and i’m thinking some sunday morning i need to hop in the car and drive to 95th street on chicago’s south side. moss, an all-american track star at morehouse college who says he heard a call to the pulpit and switched his major to religious studies then went on to yale divinity school and the chicago theological union, has deep roots in the civil rights movement. his father, otis moss jr., was an affiliate of martin luther king, jr., working together in the southern christian leadership conference, and serving in 1971 as co-pastor with king’s father, martin luther king, sr., at atlanta’s historic ebenezer baptist church.
more than worth your time are either or both of these video sermons posted on the church’s youtube channel:
last weekend, as the nation erupted in a firestorm of protest (and, sadly, pockets of violence), moss preached When Is Someday? , a sermon on the murder of george floyd and its aftermath, framed as a prelude to moss’s unforgettable sermon of the week before, The Cross and The Lynching Tree, in which he addressed the horror of the murder of yet another unarmed black man, this time ahmaud arbery, killed for the crime of taking a jog on a warm spring day in georgia.
and finally, not to be missed is trevor noah‘s powerful 18-minute video posted to his youtube account a week ago friday, reflecting on george floyd and racism in america, in which noah says:
“i don’t know what made that video more painful for people to watch. the fact that that man was having his life taken in front of our eyes, the fact that we were watching someone being murdered by someone whose job is to protect and serve, or the fact that he seemed so calm doing it. there was a black man, on the ground, in handcuffs, and you could take his life, so you did. almost knowing that there would be no ramifications.”
may these voices stir you, revivify you, and bring a speck of light and hope to this dark moment in the american story.
your thoughts always welcome here….
and before i go, happy blessed birthday to two of the chair’s dearest, amy and nan, back-to-back blessings, both blowing out candles on what i hope are sumptuous birthday cakes all across the weekend. xoxoxox
“my posture today is one bent low in the sacred prayer of listening.” Yes. Thank you for all this. Thanks, too, for the birthday wishes, tho celebrating seems moot in such a time. xoxo
Happy birthday, dear Amy! ❤
maybe more than ever wishing blessings, praying for even more courage, more grace, maybe those are the best gifts we can give those we love right now. we can celebrate the blessing of your being here, among us, at this moment in history when your light and your gentle kindness shine more radiantly than ever……
so many voices to bring to the table today. here is poet jericho brown, winner of this year’s pulitzer prize for poetry, reciting a deeply evocative “Foreday in the Morning.” one of the million things i love about poetry is the way it captures the ineffable…:
https://bittersoutherner.com/2020/the-sound-and-the-fury-of-jericho-brown-pulitzer-the-tradition
one more, more than worth your while: a documentary from the brilliant folks at the new yorker: “Quiet No More: The Struggle of the Reverend Sharon Risher.”
Risher, a hospital chaplain, lost her mother and two cousins at the Emanuel AME church in Charleston, SC, when Dylann Roof broke into a Bible study on a hot summer morning in 2015, and gunned down nine souls gathered there. Risher is also the sister of Nadine Collier, who famously forgave Roof at his bond hearing.
they are an amazing grace, the sisters nadine and sharon…..
here is sharon’s story; it’s a beauty: https://www.newyorker.com/culture/the-new-yorker-documentary/quiet-no-more-shows-how-grief-can-become-activism?utm_source=nl&utm_brand=tny&utm_mailing=TNY_Daily_060520&utm_campaign=aud-dev&utm_medium=email&bxid=5be9cb8f2ddf9c72dc17ac8e&cndid=26645371&hasha=7c634dc21796a1fd1042ee8f73e9eb68&hashb=9575a34342a07fa214fbb211da2419bc75806c23&hashc=e9900952c5bb1607093ce590a0a76e354442401d3293b204a78fa54658e1b1a9&esrc=&utm_term=TNY_Daily
Barbara, so powerful, thank you!
Imani Perry’s essay reminds me of Hildegard of Bingen’s statement: “We need to fly with two wings of awareness, one of life’s beauty and sacredness and the other of life’s pain and struggle. Both are inseparable.”
Thanks for inviting us to see both through your eyes every Friday!
beautiful. of course hildegard has wisdom. and thank you for bringing her here…..giant hug. xoxox
This Sunday morning I knew I needed to check in with you, to see how you were processing all that has been taking place, to know what you were reading, who you were looking to for inspiration just as I look to you. I was not disappointed, never am on these pages.
Thank you, bless you, keep yourself safe,
Richard
oh, dear dear richard…….finding your words here at the table, the chair, whatever this is, melts me at the start of this blessed sunday….it’s SOOOOO good to hear from you, to have an inkling that you circle back to here from time to time. nothing graces me more. i love knowing that this place is quietly here for old friends who come by as the spirit moves them.
how is your beautiful boy? please don’t say he’s graduated from high school…….or say it, and i will both rejoice and join you in understanding how deep and hard the pull is……
i send a giant hug. thank you so for coming by….xox
Dear Barbara:
Sebastian and I have just returned from playing catch on a green near our home. I had to jump directly into a hot saltz bath to soothe my aging muscles – but all is well now. I found your reply to my note and was deeply moved by your words – you cannot imagine how much I value them.
Sebastian is entering his senior year in September and knows where he wants to go to college after graduation, but before he does he wants to travel across the North American continent with a small group of friends he has known since grade school. I only hope the current troubles have dissipated by then. If they take the northern route, I will, with your permission, suggest they stop in to pay their respects. They are all fine young men.
All good things your way,
Richard
that’s funny — i’ve spent the day bent into contortions in my garden and i too am headed directly to the epsom bath! i would be SOOOO delighted and honored to meet sebastian and friends as they make that epic drive. i happen to know a great architecture critic too (married him!) and this is america’s home to architectural wonder. i cannot believe it’s almost sebastian’s senior year. and in a blink……..
bless you much. soo soo much.
savor, savor this year…..
Thank you! I will tell him – and I hope he decides to go north!
And I intend to savor every moment … in fact, you just gave me an idea.
Will keep you posted.
Yours,
Richard
Thank you for this post and its many beautiful voices, and for your kind birthday wishes. (So much going on–in my life and in our nation–that I haven’t had a moment to read and listen until this afternoon…) xo
dear birthday angel, i totally understand the so-much-going-on-ness of these days. it is a befuddlement of the highest order how the days can zip by with such a sense of fullness when we aren’t really going too far from the premises…..
anyway, i’ve been thinking of you straight through since friday, and hope your days have been sweet and stitched with wonder knots of joys and delights, the very sort you stitch into the every day…..
xoxox
Thanks for sharing all these resources here. I have been sort of overwhelmed with all the information pouring forth from so many places.
I watched Trevor Noah’s powerful statement. So much to consider there especially his view on the violence and the looting that grew from some of the protests.
I’m joining up with a group from the school where I work to read How to be an Antiracist this summer. We’re having a couple of book discussions on it over these next two months. I’m trying to learn and unlearn all at the same time.
John is reading Black Boy by Richard Wright. We are trying mightily to decolonize our book reading this summer.
Another book we both just finished reading was Apeirogon by Colum McCann. It is a powerful story beautifully written about two fathers, one Israeli and one Palestinian, who lost daughters to violence. There is so much in this novel that resonates with the racial situation here.
Hoping all this reading and reflecting along with protesting and praying and petition signing and postcard writing sets us up for some kind of overhaul of our systemic structures.
oh, i hope so, too. great list of books you’ve added here. thank you.
i know it sometimes feels like we’re trying to catch a drink from a firehose. i just quietly leave snippets here, so that they’re in one place, and available for clicking any time. the Colum McCann sounds mighty powerful……again, thank you thank you, for bringing your book lists here. i know you are a mighty reader. xox