when baseballs break a heart: a lesson you wish a kid didn’t need to learn
by bam
the night before, we laid out the uniform. the spic ‘n’ span white pants, the socks and shirt and hat the color of a rubber ducky.
the mitt, nearly sacramental, was laid on top. the final offering, it seemed, to the gods of baseball. or maybe merely to the patron saints, the ones whose job it was, you’d think, to look down on little diamonds dotted all across america, make sure no hearts were broken. not needlessly anyway.
when it comes to baseball and hearts, the sound of cracking hardly comes from bats alone, biting into balls. plenty of chambers, too, are splintered, emptied out of blood and hopes and dreams.
that’s pretty much the way it went last sunday, when the plumbers took the field. and walked off five innings later thoroughly, well, tanked.
but that’s getting ahead of the ball here.
what happened the other day was, like so much of life, teeter-tottered. one team was made up of little squirts, second graders new at baseball and pitching and hitting without a tee, and the other team was, well, old hands. and huge, by the way. third graders who’d been around the bases plenty of times.
it was the opening game of the pinto season, the league the little kids look up to, the first one where you get to don the catcher’s garb–the caged helmet, the strap between the legs, the padded shield, oh my–and kids, not coaches, get to pitch.
it’s the league of little players’ dreams. and just the day before they’d gathered for as old-fashioned a welcoming ceremony as you could imagine, complete with red-white-and-blue bunting on the outfield fence, 50-cent donut holes, dugouts, and a pledge to “make it fun; above all, make it fun.”
well, before the teams took to the grass and sand-strewn mounds, even a mope like me could tell that somehow something was off-kilter. felt a bit like goldilocks, one team too little, the other too, too big.
but it wasn’t the kids so much as the coaches, who quickly emerged as big bad bears.
there were two, in particular, on the other team. one a beefy guy who wore his Big Ten football jersey beneath his little league t-shirt. the other: lean, in khaki trousers, not smiling.
those two coaches took on this game as if it was some sort of season-ending series, and their life and lungs depended on a win.
from the get-go they were whoopin’ and bellowing. tellin’ one player or another to knock it off. hustle. hustle. CHASE THE BALL, KID, WHAT ARE YA THINKIN’?!?
right off, they encouraged stealing bases. a kid would hit, the little plumbers out in the far-out field would fumble for the ball, chase it half a mile, and all the while the coaches would be spinning round their arm, like some cockeyed windmill, fanning in another run.
didn’t take long for the little ones to take on a dazed sort of expression. reminded me of what cake batter must feel like when the metal whirring beaters are dropped into its midst. poor soupy batter just stands back and takes it, till at last the instructions on the back of the box say to stop, two minutes, up.
inning after inning it went like this: kids from the other team stepped up to the plate, hit, ran, stole, scored. ran through the lineup nearly every time.
scored run after run after run. after run. and that was just the first inning.
then the little guys got a turn. three up, three down. boom, boom, boom. three strikes, yer out. three outs, yer on the field.
pretty soon the score was 20 to nothing.
after an inning or three, we lost count. but the coaches on the other team never let up. they were calling out the batters’ names, four or five at a time, assuming i suppose that they’d bat forever, without a single out.
wasn’t long before the kids on the Big Ten coach’s team picked up on this knuckle-thumping bravado. they’d bellow out the score from time to time, a pathetic count that rose–on one side only, thank you–like mercury on a steamy august day.
alas, inning after inning, the little plumbers stayed stuck at the hollowest of numbers.
“it’s 35 to zero,” one kid from the other team called out, in case anyone was listening. yelled it so loud, made me fairly certain he was making sure kids two towns away would know the score.
the coach said nothing; i couldn’t help myself. i’d been muttering in whispers long enough. it was time to politely make a point.
“how ‘bout some humility,” i mentioned–softly–to no one in particular, in case anyone was listening. i got poked in the ribs by the chap sitting next to me. told me to cool it, he did. and i guess, because he’s the man i married, he was just tryin’ to keep me safe. from coaches and their trounce-announcing players.
oh, it’s a happy place, this sandlot baseball.
worst part, though, was hours later. at bedtime. of course, when all the muddy waters of the day come rushing out, and rinsing needs be done.
the little one, no surprise, couldn’t fall asleep, and soon had called for help.
“i can’t sleep,” he yelled in apt description.
seems the whole darn game, inning after inning, was playing in his head: the fly ball he’d missed, the one that let the batter earn a triple; the strike-out the only time he got to bat; the foul tip that got away.
wasn’t long before the tears came too.
“we lost by 43,” he said, demonstrating second-grade subtraction skills. “that’s half of a hundred,” he said, demonstrating wide-eyed approximation.
demonstrating, too, just how bad it hurt, to be a little kid with giant baseball dreams who’d had them thoroughly, undeniably trampled. rubbed-in like grass stains on his once-white knees.
just the night before, this would-be catcher-slash-center-fielder had had trouble falling asleep with all the home-run pictures in his head. heard the crowd roaring, he did. imagined the coach handing him the little plunger that, each game, goes to the plumbers’ player-of-the-game.
and now, one game later, he’d seen the way it really was: coaches past their prime taking on the task as if a win, at any cost, was all that mattered. paying no mind to pint-sized kids and their first outing on the field. waving in runners twice the size of the little ones fumbling under bushes, trying to throw the ball anywhere in the vicinity of a base.
it hurt, the poor kid said.
he was mad and sad and thoroughly confused: baseball was a game he loved. a game he watched at night, lying beside his papa. a game he read about every morning, slurping statistics along with frosted flakes.
and now, because of baseball, he felt, he said, like someone put their baseball cleat right where his heart goes thump, and then, with all their weight, they’d pushed down that cleated sole.
it hurt, he said.
and then, at last, he fell asleep.
his mitt, that night, was nowhere near his bed. he’d dumped it, soon as he came in the door. his yellow hat, though, hung on the post of his bed; he wasn’t giving up.
just poring over pages in the play book, trying to figure out the game.
when i walked in a little later on, to kiss him one last time, his cheek was soggy still. he’d cried himself to sleep.
some lesson learned on the ballfield that sorry sunday: you can give it all you’ve got and then some, but some beefy guys will run you bloody. and hoot and holler all the way to home.
not why i signed up the kid for baseball.
do you think, perhaps, i could get my money back?
the questions are these: what lessons have you learned on some ball field somewhere, lessons you still don’t think you needed to know? or, conversely, if you’ve found yourself sitting in the stands, or drying tears at bedtime, how did you patch a player’s broken heart?
housekeeping: this is my first friday meander on the new rhythm, and while i ached to write on wednesday, it is something of a treat to wrap up my writing week here, where i can meander to my heart’s content. welcome to the new world, i suppose. maybe fridays will be all right. maybe it makes sense to emphatically end my week, and start the blessed weekend. thanks for adjusting.
and finally, a huge and hearty welcome to a few fine souls who’ve just recently told me that they’ve found the chair. the mama of a boy who long long ago was my patient, a boy with cancer who i, along with a few other heavenly nurses, cared for, and quickly came to love. jeffrey died, but his mama comes here now, one of the miracles of the chair and life. and a lovely writer named julia, who is in 7th grade, and who is going to grow up to knock your socks off with what she writes and the questions she asks. it is the most blushing thing, thoroughly a blessing, to find out that extraordinary souls have tiptoed here and quietly pulled out a chair. it gives me goosebumps every time. bless you each and every one. and welcome.
19 comments:
pjv
Oh goodness … reminds me of our year in 4th-5th grade co-ed volleyball. My little one is one of the smallest ones in her class and, hard as she tried, could never get that ball near the net, much less serve it over. Heartache, I tell ya. Our team lost every single game. It was so hard to watch the other teams, much more practiced and skilled than ours, beat us every single time. I bit my lip so hard that I’d leave there tied up in knots. I tried to teach my little Joey that trying her best, while not always achieving the win, made her a better team player and stronger for the next try. I don’t think she bougtht it for a second, but it was worth a shot.
I remember pee-wee baseball (as we used to call it) had something called a Mercy Rule. The game would be called if it became so lopsided that it would take an act of God for the losing team to catch up. Does this rule not apply anymore?
Tell that little curly haired boy that he’s still the MVP in my book.
Friday, May 15, 2009 – 03:32 PM
pjv
oops … almost forgot to wish little baby Elena a happy one-month birthday!
Friday, May 15, 2009 – 07:49 PM
hh
It was called the slaughter rule when my son played — can’t remember how many runs ahead the other team had to be before the game was called, but I’m pretty sure it was less than 15. I really think 45 to 2 is criminal.
When my not so little one played he was on teams that lost every game and on teams that won virtually every game. Thankfully, his coaches were generally stand-up guys. But he certainly played against teams with coaches like the bullies you described. My mild-mannered husband, on one memorable occasion, let the bullies know exactly how he felt — didn’t change anything, but made him feel better I think and made our little boy and the other boys and their parents feel a little better too.
Friday, May 15, 2009 – 09:40 PM
Carol
Parents are too involved in their kids sports these days in general. None of these are pick up games in the neighborhood, with mixed ages and kids picking teams. This is now all so organized. However, there should also be learning outcomes from having so much adult involvement, and I think one should be good sportsmanship (maybe an inservice is needed for the parent coaches). I heard a professional ball player talk once and he said that it is important to respect (not trash) one’s opponent, because without opponents, there would be no game. Report back what the commissioner says!
Friday, May 15, 2009 – 10:27 PM
anne
Who knew ‘winning ugly’ would migrate to the North Shore?!
However, in all honesty, you live in Type A territory. Fast, furious but not always fun. And baseball is a sport where in the pros, success is apparently due to “enhanced performance drugs.” That’s what I would always ponder, watching the little league games. All that flag waving and patriotism and then the boys graduate to… the steroids.
Patching up the player’s broken heart is a tough job. No advice there except provide as many hugs as the player will accept. Sometimes even hugs are no consolation though.
What did your son’s coaches say after the game?
(Have you seen the original Bad News Bears lately – the one with Walter Matthau? It REALLY captures the trauma found on baseball diamonds everywhere.)
Saturday, May 16, 2009 – 02:09 PM
bam
dear anne, so the zillion dollar question is, what to do when you live in type A land, but don’t share the zeal for always always winning. and don’t believe a tough heart is such a good thing. in fact you would NEVER want one?????
it’s the very reason i worried moving here, and it’s why so often i live in my hermit zone. (which you might never guess if you met me, smiling, on the street…) i’ve made it something of a challenge to sniff out kindred spirits here and am emboldened thusly. now if one such would take over as commissioner of baseball, all would be grand. i once daydreamed of starting a school only for the tender of heart. no bullies allowed. i can hear folks snickering at me as i type that, but that’s why we have the chair. because those who pull up here, thank God, are tender tooo…..
Saturday, May 16, 2009 – 02:24 PM
MB
“Love is the force that ignites the spirit and binds teams together.”
Phil Jackson, former coach for the Chicago Bulls – the winning Bulls!
He is certainly no minor player on the field of sports.
Saturday, May 16, 2009 – 07:13 PM
JACK
Most of what I’ve learned on the baseball diamond has been as harsh as what your little guy learned. Unfortunately, coaches/parents with that “win at all costs” attitude will never go away. It is so hard on our younger ones, but yet they seem to sometimes have the wisdom to see that the bully coach is not the right example of how a game should be played. Because, after all, baseball is nothing more than a game that little boys, and girls, play. I do hope that the next Plumbers’ outing was more successful.
Keep those white pants as spic and span as they were at the beginning of the season. That’s a visual connection to the love that is waiting back at home, the orderliness that can be found in this chaotic world, the joy that a good night snuggle with mom will bring.
Monday, May 18, 2009 – 12:25 PM
pjv
Perhaps the pristine uniform is representative of how we want to keep our kids … clean and free of the filth that awaits them in the world. As parents, we want to wash away all of the things that society today wants to stain them with … there’s something very nobile about that. If the world is a rocky place, I want my children to know that there’s a soft landing pad here for them at home.
No matter what neighborhood you live in or what ‘type’ you are … a poor sport is still a poor sport.
Monday, May 18, 2009 – 07:21 PM
pjv
Oops … meant to type ‘noble’, not nobile. That’s what I get for typing in the dark.
Monday, May 18, 2009 – 07:22 PM
Uncle Michael
Hey Ted!
I just googled Babe Ruth, and read that in his 22 year career in the big leagues, yes he hit 714 home runs, a record for many years until Hammerin’ Hank eclipsed it, but Babe Ruth had a whopping 1330 strike outs in his career!
That means for every ONE time Babe Ruth hit a home run and waltzed around the bases, there were TWO times he walked back to the dugout after striking out.
And he’s in the Baseball Hall of Fame, a legend.
The only question to ask yourself when you get your butt beat like you did, is,
“What can I do to improve my game?” And get busy. Your Uncle Michael got his butt whupped plenty of times. All it did was make me more determined.
Champions don’t always win, they just NEVER quit, and they keep improving their athletic skills, and LAUGH at whatever is funny. It’s a game, remember.
I’m proud of you, Ted. When’s your next game?
Tuesday, May 19, 2009 – 01:26 AM
NJK
We are constantly preparing kids for people who lack civility:
A quote from “Choosing Civility
The Twenty-Five Rules of Considerate Conduct,” By P.M. Forni
“Suppose that instead we fostered among the young the belief that although it is important to win, how we play the game is even more important. Suppose we convinced them that we play the game well when we play it to the best of our abilities, respecting both the rules of the game and our opponents. Imagine the changes the new frame of mind would bring. Here is a new society where we can lose a game still be happy with what we did. We might not like the final score, but what really matters, the fact that we played the game well, following our heart and our conscience, cannot be taken away from us. Thus defeat becomes bearable, a learning opportunity rather than a crushing blow. We can easily make peace with it, leave it behind us, and look forward to our next win. But then, in a way, we are already winners. This is civility: the ability to internalize the notion that how you play the game is more important than the final score.”
As a soccer and hockey mom, I saw it all. You just want to make them wake up and understand the damage they do! Those kinds of people have never been open to my “suggestions”.
Wednesday, May 20, 2009 – 12:06 PM
bam
people, read the above comment carefully. it comes from a beloved brilliant teacher whose wisdom once made me nearly drive off the road. hmm, you say, some recommendation. well here’s the story…
my firstborn was blessed to be in her gym class in kindergarten at the esteemed lab schools of university of chicago, and as i was driving him home along lake shore drive, right where it takes that sharp turn to the left, before jogging north. well from the back seat he pipes up about the “life lesson” he learned that day. and then went on with an amazing bit of brilliance all courtesy of one of the most beloved teachers ever. yup, njk is a teacher who from the start teaches children how to play the game of life. i adore her. everything about her, and what an honor to find her still sharing wisdom. especially for my little one who didn’t get the honor of being in her fold.
love, bam
Wednesday, May 20, 2009 – 03:34 PM
Uncle
When you take the field, you RISK winning or losing–no guarantees here. So you play your utmost, take what comes, learn your lesson(s), and move on… Isn’t that the way life is? Or, do we somehow try to “control” the outcome, and alter the simple reality that takes place. Let the children play. Let them laugh, cry, learn and grow.
Thursday, May 21, 2009 – 09:50 AM
jimmijo34
the plumbers did’nt quit,nor did they pout,call names or exhibit poor sportsmanship. THEY TRIED THEIR BEST. i’m sorry your son had to learn this lesson this way but its a lesson well learned. your kids showed class,the so called ‘Adults’ coaching these kids did not.The plumbers may have lost a game,but they are the true winners,they may not understand this now,but they will learn class & sportsmanship will always win out. GO PLUMBERS
Monday, June 8, 2009 – 10:26 AM
bam
i think everyone was so stunned it was happening, and i am not sure what quietly might have been communicated toward the very end of the game, from coach to coach. or father to father. i know that we have excellent coaches, who put their hearts into every game. and i know that my husband wasn’t happy. but when i write i write about how i perceive what happens, and i don’t speak for him. he was heartsick over what happened to our little guy. i write to try to understand. i write to try to shine light on what seems wrong. i write to hear the wisdom of those who pull up chairs.
Monday, June 8, 2009 – 10:53 PM
bam
thank you for meandering over here and sharing your side of the story. i DO appreciate hearing it from your perspective. i don’t think any of us had the score right, and the score is not the point (although in my little one’s head and at least a few other kids’ they thought it was 45-2, and feeling trounced by that much is part of the story). i definitely heard a kid shout out, it’s 35 to nothing.
i understand that it’s just a game. and i do hear what you are saying about how you were trying to teach em the rules, and how it sure wasn’t your fault that the 3d graders on the plumbers didn’t show up. i understand the pickle you were in, so i guess my point would be that it was the WAY you never slowed the slaughter that was disconcerting. but maybe this is just the way little league is supposed to be. i was not whining about not winning. oh, lord. i would never ever write about that. i am actually a pretty level-headed soul, and a pacifist at that. what i was disturbed by–and i know i was not the only one–was that once it became soooooo apparent that it was way lopsided, the hard-charging never let up. not until one of the plumber coaches did go talk to someone and ask for a little let-up.
all i was saying was that on one chilly sunday, watching coaches wave their arms round and round, it was a hard game to watch. that’s it. we all have our days. and i will give them all the credit in the world for stepping up to the plate.
the point here was to say that some big questions are raised on a ballfield, and at bedtimes afterward, and how does a parent figure out how to use the tough lessons, and go on stronger…..
Friday, June 12, 2009 – 08:28 AM
bam
my beloved chair friends (and you know who you are….),
i just want to say, i just re-read through the comments from blessed pjv on top, on down to the bottom. i cannot tell you how beautiful and peaceful your words are, all of you who understand the essence here. there is so much heart, and so much wisdom packed in comment upon comment. i love how you never took your eye off the ball, and kept your comments focused on how to instill heart and kindness and tenderness and fairness in a growing child. isn’t that the thing that matters? and aren’t you blessed, for the collective wisdom you bring here, and bring to my life–and the lives of those touched by this holy sacred place. for three years this has been a place where gentleness reigns. i always treasure that, even more so now.
Saturday, June 13, 2009 – 11:09 PM
In favor of good sportsmanship
Dear Pull Up a Chair:
Congratulations on drawing attention to this sensitive subject, which is often whispered about, but rarely discussed in public. It looks like your story struck a nerve. The Chicago Tribune printed this letter in yesterday’s paper.
Kids’ sports
I read Barbara Mahany’s “Bad day at diamond leaves Little Leaguer in the rough” (News, June 8) with some mixed memories. My little guy is now a 22-year-old, recently minted, college grad and aspiring journalist. His game was basketball from the earliest opportunity through college, but the story line was the same, one of dreams the night before and tears the night of, brought about at too early an age by people who just plain should have known better and had some compassion.
These are kids, not pawns for bragging rights. Playing sports is supposed to be fun, especially at that age. Let “win at all costs” come later.
I remember watching a particularly lopsided high school baseball game; “our guys” were winning hugely and there wasn’t a slaughter rule. And “our” coach forfeited our team’s at-bat for at least one if not two innings so as to lessen the pain to the opposing team. Result was our team still won, as it would have, but in the process learned a great lesson about compassion and sportsmanship, one which would be remembered far longer by both teams than the score of a lopsided game.
I wish Mahany’s little guy luck; I hope she tells him to have fun and enjoy every game. And she should try to cherish all of these moments. It was a bittersweet day last March when I watched my son suit up and play in what would be his last organized game. It was too soon for him to be an adult and moving on, and much too soon for me to be saying goodbye to what was once my little guy.
— Jim Kaplan, Glencoe
Monday, June 15, 2009 – 09:48 AM