taking up the challah challenge
by bam
years and years ago, when my kitchen confidence was far wobblier than it is now, i tried my hand at friday challah baking. i wound up with paddles of braided bread that appeared amphibian and reptilian. there were a couple weeks of challah masquerading as crocodile. challah as lobster, with vengeful claws reaching across the table. my challahs looked anything but edible. my challahs begged for names. and cages.
so i surrendered, bought my weekly challah at the grocery store. but, because it comes only in sizes fit for half a synagogue, we almost always have leftover loaves hardening in the corner. i have a slew of ways to use it: i’ve frozen so many picked-over loaves a peek in our freezer might make you think we eat one and only one foodstuff — challah in varying stages of ice age; i’ve mastered bread pudding and french toast (can do both with my eyes closed); we’ve sliced it for a million saturday PB&Js; and of course our squirrels get a steady diet (i wouldn’t be surprised if our squirrels know the hamotzi, the challah blessing, by now).
and every friday night i’ve sat across the table from that oversized soul-less loaf, and dared myself to take up the challah challenge: “take a deep breath, and a humble packet of baker’s yeast, and see if you can once again find it in yourself to pull two golden braids from the oven, adorn your friday night shabbat table with bread you’ve kneaded and blessed with silent incantations all on your own, start to finish.”
yesterday, in full trial mode, i dove in. i am here to tell you that instant yeast is nothing to be afraid of. (this declaration is nothing short of revolutionary for a girl who grew up in a house where yeast was spoken of in hushed tones, as if a living-breathing creature that might wreak uncharted havoc if not treated kindly and gently enough. and, yes, my mother baked bread often in those radical suburban ’70s, so the misappropriation of fear and loathing is all my own. she is hereby declared innocent of that particular quirk of mine. now pie crust, that’s another story….)
i turned once again to the step-by-step instructions of my challah-baking friend and long-ago ally, henry, who with his family had escaped nazi germany, and who regaled me with tales of his mama’s friday baking and her magnificent golden braided loaves back in the old country, before all was shattered. though the pages now have yellowed, i found henry’s instruction clear and encouraging as ever, as i pulled his three stapled sheets from my cookery file, and followed along, triumphant at each and every stage. because i was baking challah on a thursday, there was something of an experimental air to the whole shebang. didn’t matter if i flubbed it. didn’t matter if it never rose (though i would have felt my heart deflate right along with the lack of yeasty rise).
and i was all but jubilant when, at quarter to three, i pulled from my wobbly old oven (it gets as hot or warm as it’s inclined on any given day, paying no mind to the faded numbers on the oven dial), two sturdy loaves. two loaves studded with sesame and poppy, onion bits and garlic, too (i had bagel topping in the pantry and figured it wouldn’t hurt to sprinkle with abandon — i was later informed to ditch the bagel topping, “this isn’t a bagel, mom,” and go the purist route: sesame or poppy, not both, not ever again).
i’m hardly exaggerating to declare my two loaves adorable. (see photo above!) after admiring abundantly, the taste-testers dove in. besides the plea to ditch the bagel-y topping, there came a request to please make it “eggier.” i’ve already consulted “the bread baker’s apprentice,” written by the master of bread, peter reinhart, aka brother juniper. he’s got a roadmap riddled with eggs — two whole + two yolks, and a host of other instructions besides.
so next week it’s challah 2.0, and i’ll keep at it till i’ve mastered these doughy batons. not long ago i met a woman who bakes like a fiend and, come friday afternoons, she piles her back seat with challahs galore, and drives and delivers to a circle of loved ones numbering into the 20s. i’d like that. imagine myself, pewter hair flapping out the driver’s side window, as i steer my station wagon — aka the challah mobile — hither and yon, flinging loaves as i go.
it’s all part of a scheme to infuse more intentionality into my days. to conquer those wee quirky fears, the ones that stand in the way of the bigger more daunting ones. slay a little dragon, and perhaps you muster the muscle to take on the giants. and in the meantime it quiets my fridays, ushers in the holiness of shabbat in the hours when i’m alone. i know enough of the meditative calm that comes with kneading and waiting, waiting and punching down dough, waiting some more. to bring to the table a loaf, blessedly braided, a loaf into which i’ve infused my prayers, a loaf just the right size for the two of us who, henceforth, will be the two main players at our shabbat table, once the youngin shoves off for college. it’s holy, all right. and triumphant besides.
and it sates a hunger of the most soulful kind.
a few fun challah facts from my friend brother juniper: garnishing the loaves with seeds, either sesame or poppy, symbolizes the falling of manna from heaven, and the covering of the challah with a cloth as it’s served on shabbat represents the heavenly dew that protects the manna. how lovely is that? so lovely.
what little dragon might you already have slain, or determined to slay, in this blessed new year, a chance to rise again?
So happy to see your are diving headlong into bread!! I am excited to hear more about it!
of course, of course, five-sixths of my inspiration comes from you: baker of the best bread i have ever eaten. i make such declarations not lightly. you’re a genius in the bread department. and i think it’s something of the sacred in your bread that made me break through my wall of hesitations, plunge in to infuse the sacred into the Shabbat challah. i do have questions about making it more whole wheat than unbleached. if a recipe calls for four cups unbleached bread flour, can i swap out one of those cups for whole wheat, and where else might the equation need to be shifted? more yeast? more water? i think i am going to go with brother juniper’s recipe next week. this is going to be very much a work in progress. i wonder if some day we might have a belle plaine bread tutorial, a real live one? that would be so heavenly. but i am guessing for you much of the sanctity is in the silence of your baking……
xoxox
Oh dear. How did I miss this?!? Oh I’m so sorry for the belated nature of my reply!
Yes to wheat substitution – start with 1 cup, slightly increase liquid & yeast. If you like the result, go for 1.5 or even 2 cups & again, slightly increase liquid & yeast. Experiment until you find the ratio that yields a loaf you are satisfied by!
My mom ran a cooking school out of our house for the better part of 20 years (about 10 of which I was living in the house) which is where my loves of baking & cooking we’re birthed. I would love to teach a “class” on baking bread. It’s so delightfully simple the way I approach it!! Given the late-ish stage of this pregnancy, I think it’s a dream that will need to wait for 2020, sometimes the best things percolate for awhile before bursting out into real life. Maybe this is one of them!?!
Sorry again for being a doofus with technology & completely missing your comment!
oh, dear gracious! i have no idea how you found the comment and questions but i am so happy you did. it’s never too late for an answer to bread-alchemy questions. ohhhhhh, i would so love to take a class from you. what a treat to grow up in a cooking school, one led by your very own mama. i’m not baking much right now in the depth of summer (my garden muddy hands tell the secret of what i’ve been up to!) but soon as i am back in bread making mode, i will work on the LKK ratio……
xoxoxo
They are gorgeous! We are very proud of you. How I long to be baking beside you and delivering them hither and yon. Using the Ravinia cookbook, my spouse weaves an onion/paprika mix thru it…yum.
oh YUM!!!! that is sooo wild that your sweet mate makes it at your house. or do you both do it together? i nearly fell over last night when my BK said, out of the blue, that he wanted to make it with me!!!!! there must be something in the recipe that calls out to our jewish beloveds……
Wowie!!! Well done!!!! 🥰
at least no claws this time!
I bet they tasted good regardless!!
I’m feeling some synchronicity here! This morning the woman I work with, an Orthodox Jew, brought me a homemade challah fresh from the oven.
i LOVE that!!!!! give me a few weeks/months, and i’ll be making the rounds with my challah batons!!!!
Chuckle, chuckle – the picture of your flinging your manna offerings to those
observers of Shabbat and otherwise who await in sweet anticipation. Alas, I must now be content with Challah for one, which means even after alternative concoctions, my freezer becomes deluged with the surplus. I now
obtain the smaller loaf from local golden- handed baker and fling remainders
to the birds above for Shabbat blessing. Would love to join you and Liz for
the sanctioned ritual of creating Friday Challah that ultimately blesses all..
Loved the line ” much of the sanctity is in the silence of your baking.” as is
so with most dedicated endeavors….. Shabbat shalom, dear Friend…
oh, that would be so heavenly. can you see all of us then flinging our braided loves from our challah wagons, hither and yon about the countryside….
you are blessed to have a golden-handed baker. and i am too: our liz<3, an angel of a soul if ever there was…..
YUM, YUM AND YUM!!! xox
busy making a whole wheat version today, but as the timer just clanged and it’s supposed to be double in size, something curious is going on and it’s not yet double at all. hmmmmm. will give it more time.