a voice at the table
by bam
growing up, the table at my house was rather crowded. there were five of us little people, four of us bunched every other year, and then, enough years later to surprise the dickens out of me the day we got the news of the impending arrival, the so-called caboose. blessed caboose.
at the head of every dinner table, in the door like clockwork from the 6:20 train and plunked at the south end of the table, a man who made his living with a typewriter that he pounded late into the night, and a microphone that he carried ‘round the globe.
i cannot for the life of me remember much of the chatter. but i do remember that there was plenty. and i seem to recall that it was hard to get a word in edgewise.
i remember plenty of spilled milk. and the occasional night when i was left to contemplate the peas, the peas that i did not want to eat, the peas that i had so artfully—i thought—tucked beneath the rim of the plate. but eagle eyes herself, my mother, didn’t miss that sleight of legume. so there i sat, silent, miserable, convinced i was the only child in the world left to wither overnight staring at my uneaten, unwanted mushy peas.
i remember in high school a few dining room debates with my father. i was on the side of world hunger. he, ad man for mcdonald’s, was going to bat for big mac. how dare they, i wailed, blaming the golden arches for all that was wrong on the starving continents of the world. how dare i, he thundered back. only, come to think of it, i don’t think thunder would be my father’s verb. i think he was, maybe, solid wall of atmospheric front. not budging, firmly stationed. but not too terribly noisy, either. he made his point, in fact, without too much thunder.
mostly, i remember that he was the most amazing tightrope walker i had ever seen. only his tightrope was a string of words. puns, punch lines, quick wit, those were the tricks with which he dazzled while edging along the taut fine cord strung from one end of the table to the other.
if you could play along, he reached out a hand and lifted you too onto the tightrope, the high wire. you too could swing on my papa’s verbal trapeze. but you’d better be quick. better yet, you could shine if you could match him, come back at him, hook your foot to word cord, and do a loopdy-loop.
it was hard sometimes to make it through a meal. you’d be out of breath, just trying to keep up. it was exercise, getting through the word play that was my family dinner.
i got a workout, all right. but it took a long, long time ’til i found i had a voice, a true deep voice, that i could bring to the table.
the first place to which i brought my voice was blank, blue-lined notebook paper. i wrote in pencil, then pen, long before my fingers knew to land on a, s, d, f, over to the left, and p, l, m, n, cascading down the right.
i remember, long ago, realizing i had become a writer because i finally found a voice. i had found it hard, very hard, to speak deeply from my heart at my dinner table, what with all the tightrope walking and debating all-beef patties versus kwashiorkor’s swollen-belly babies.
i remember, vividly, the night i took a seat at my little maple table. and the man on the other end of the table, a man i’d never eaten with before, a man i’d never before offered a chair at my table, asked me what i wanted in my life. i remember leaning back, laughing, thinking, saying, all at once, “i feel like i could talk to you the rest of my life.”
that man, now my husband, still sits across from me nearly every night at dinner. almost 20 years later, i still laugh, say the same thing. we’re still very much talking.
the amazing thing when you marry is that you get a chance to study closely yet another family. one of the first—and most lasting—things i noticed about my husband’s family was, is, how they sit for hours at the table, really talking, really listening.
is it any wonder, i sometimes wonder, that i was drawn so deeply to a man who so easily, so finely, really, brings his voice to the table. and, most of all, makes room for mine.
it is, of all the gifts we give our children, the one i’d pencil in way, way up, seriously high, at practically the sky-scraping top of the list. it is the gift of being heard at the dinner table.
over the years, as a gatherer of newspaper stories, i have interviewed some truly amazing human beings. the refrain, so often–when asked, what was the elmer’s glue that held you together, that made you who you are–was, time and again, something about always sitting down to dinner. as a family. no matter the hour. no matter the menu. what mattered was that everybody had a place and a voice at the table.
now, i am here to tell you that the eight years between boy 1 and boy 2 at our house make for some rough sledding at the dinner table some nights.
while we zero in on boy 1, intent on probing deep into his oh-so-thoughtful soul, boy 2 decides to slide off his chair and play puppy dog, licking at our legs. or, for variety, he might drop spaghetti, strand by strand, onto the floor, until someone notices the heap and, inconveniently, hits the pause button on what had been boy 1’s careful analysis of al gore and his global-warming truths.
and some nights, i kid you not, it all gets messy. and i don’t mean the scraps dropping to the floor. conversation, when it’s real, is not all clean and tidy. and there are nights at our house, when salty tears add flavor to the food.
but we won’t relent. won’t back down. won’t give in to puppy dogs under tables, or spaghetti balls piling higher with every passing sentence. tears are dried. turns are taken.
the little one, up off the floor, gets his turn. he always does. the little one has 12 more years of family dinners, before he heads off to have his dinners elsewhere. God and admissions boards willing, in some college cafeteria. the big one has only four more years.
the one thing i pray for both my boys is that they look back at the maple kitchen table, or the cherry one in the dining room, and they remember that there, at their places along the east and western edges, they might not always have brought clean hands but they always brought their voices. their deep, rich, steady voices.
and at those tables, the voices always had a place, room to stretch out, to try out new ideas from different angles, to practice thinking. to be heard.
yes, most of all, the table was a place where voices, soft or loud, it didn’t matter, were always, always heard.
certainly, it is the essence of pull up a chair. finding a place at the table where you can boldly bring a voice. where you can pour your thoughts, your heart, your soul. what is dinner like at your house? where, at your house, do you find the fine art of conversation most freely unfolds?

13 comments:
Brother Michael
I grew up at the same table, where the food was comforting, and the conversation was dangerous. It seemed like no one ever finished a sentence. Someone would start one and the chorus would cut it off. From that I learned to speak in staccato phrases–which is useful in some settings.
I only learned to speak complete sentences while in my 20’s some 2000 miles away in a world of my own choosing, at a different board, a keyboard, where I have given almost 50,000 lessons–one-on-one, hearing my students develop their voices musically and verbally. There’s something so satisfying at that “board” …
It takes time to find your voice, to feel your groove. And you need somebody’s love to help you get there.
My heart always longs for “a table where voices are always heard.” Thank you, Barbie, for striking another dominant chord. Selah.
Friday, May 4, 2007 – 09:32 AM
PJV-AZ
Oh my, what I wouldn’t give to travel back in time and sit at the Mahany dinner table. Growing up, my father held a strict ‘children seen, not heard’ policy at the table. Very little was shared because my father liked to eat in peace and quiet after a hard day at work.
Today, it’s quicky becoming a rare occasion when we all sit down at the dinner table together what with so many schedules competing for our time. But it makes me so happy to set the table and dine together. Sadly, family dinner table conversation is becoming a lost art in America. A myriad of activities play tug-o-war with family time.
I so enjoy lingering around after the meal is finished sipping coffee from my favorite cup, talking and catching up. It’s far too infrequent for my well being.
Friday, May 4, 2007 – 04:14 PM
lamcal
Grew up in a house of 10 and had such a similar experience…laughter, teasing, always plenty of food, conversation, and intense political debates! My dad always called me (in a somewhat fond manner) his “Jane Fonda commy pinko daughter” which may give a sense of my age and the times!! It is good, but sad in a way, that my present family of 5 are all pretty much of the same mindset so conversation is not nearly as comical and explosive as I remember from my Barry Goldwater Father and my Kennedy Mother. Oh did we learn alot from watching and listening. It got even better at Sunday dinner when there were always extra guests – including “Judgie” – my grandfather the judge, who would always nod off in his chair by the end of dinner while Ma (grandmother) bustled around him and told us all to just go on being as loud as we wanted ~ serve him right if we woke him up. Nothing would ever wake him up though….
I also remember sitting at the kitchen table till bedtime…staring at those darned peas! I am over that now and am wondering about you?!
Friday, May 4, 2007 – 05:59 PM
Brother Michael
Dear ‘commie pinko’–
How colorful! Loved your comment. Too bad home movies of that era were silent…but your memories are audio-visual no doubt. Thanks for sharing the wealth. Your upbringing gave you a greater grasp of democracy than most of us have…
🙂
Friday, May 4, 2007 – 08:23 PM
Brother Michael
Hey PJV-AZ
How YOU doin’? Always love reading your crosstown comments on a blog based 2000 miles from here! I’ve sat at your table and laughed and had my heart warmed “lingering around after the meal,” just like you said. Your table has an inviting, gracious glow.
Friday, May 4, 2007 – 08:38 PM
PJV-AZ
Yo, Bro Michael!
How YOU doin’ my friend?! Right back at ya. You know you’re always welcome at my table … in fact, it’s been WAY too long. Our door will forever be open to you. Let’s break bread real soon. :o)
Friday, May 4, 2007 – 10:03 PM
jcv
The table of my childhood was a sort of survival of the fittest affair. No parents, three brothers, and me. Let me just say quickly that no “voice” of mine was developed here. And all the while I dreamed of those merry warm conversational dinner tables which lived in my imagination.
Things were closer to the mark in graduate school, in a lively household with five roommates and an ever-changing roster of impromptu dinner guests. Each of us was given a hearing and almost always appreciated.
Now in my own home where I’m the grown-up we’ve got issues of the disruptive-spaghetti-dropper sort, and sometimes I find myself wishing for just an ounce of the seen-and-not-heard of pjv’s unhappy memory…just a smidgeon. The plus side, I suppose, is that perhaps these little ones will not require 40 years to find their voices. Or maybe it just takes that long no matter what. I don’t know. All I do know is that the key to finding one’s voice is being heard, being really and truly heard and being understood.
p.s. to PJV-AZ and Brother Michael, I sure am jealous of you over there in the Blessed Homeland, and someday when I’m back in my old stomping grounds I may just crash your tables.
Friday, May 4, 2007 – 10:45 PM
PJV-AZ
Hi jcv … come crash my table anytime! When you know you’ll be back on familiar soil just holler and we’ll set out a chair just for you. I’m here daily so I’m not hard to find. As I’ve told bam … this is my daily dose of wonderful.
Saturday, May 5, 2007 – 01:03 PM
uncle david (4th sibling of 5)
well now…where should i start…i’lltypelikethislikethedinnerconversationwasbackthen…oh my. brother michael, i recall when you stomped away from thetable to play the who AT LOUD VOLUMES…and the time that i dashed to basement and cracked the gallon of milk (note that i say one gallon, not a guart would do for a family of 5 catholics kids) and then i sobbed at the deed, and dad tried to make light of it, verbal gymnaxtics, and i recall the aistons, family of 10 kids, 1 great dane named makuba, 1 rooster named rody and 40 cats, neighbors who back in the early 70s were not for nixon – too much life there – but dad was.
i grilled tonight. long slow cooking. thought of brother brian, then of how NOT was this dad’s 8.5 minute hamburger. okay, to all not present growing up at 707, eugene shannon, our father, was commander in chief of his weber grill. and like his life, as at the dinner table to follow, he grilled at super high heat, high flames, pressing the burgers down to release the fatty oils and engorge the flames. OH WE LOVED THE PYROTECHNICS as boys, but now, tonight, i slow cooked ribs, long low heat to break down the collagen, and did not open the cover so as not to release the sumptuous smoke flavor. back at 707 this was heresy.
i recall other families, lawyers, cited by mom as “they LISTEN to your entire comment before responding.” this was not modus vivendi at our house. high speed, pressed for time, full volume pyrotechnics at 707.
barbara, your table welcomes discussion. ah, yes!
Saturday, May 5, 2007 – 08:37 PM
Carol
How embarassing is this?
All of you remember family members talking at dinner–whether the situation was ideal for you or not. When I was young, we had peaceful dinners–but why? My parents loved to watch “What’s My Line” (this dates me!) and whatever time it was on coincided with our dinnertime. Sooooo, they put a small TV on the table in the breakfast nook, and my parents, sisters and I all ate dinner while guessing the real job holder–say a parachuting chef–, versus the two imposters. We tried to outguess Tom Posten (sp?) or Kitty Carlisle (still alive and in her 90s) who were on the panel. When that show ended, I think it was replaced by Jeopardy, so that is what we watched. To put a positive spin on things–my mother was a good cook, so the dinner was nice. We always ate together. The meal was always peaceful, and fun, but focused on a game show! As kids, we felt listened to at any other time–just not at dinner. The fallout of this for me might be that since I have been an adult, I have never owned a TV. I guess I got my fill–literally–during meal times in my formative years.
Monday, May 7, 2007 – 12:14 AM
jcv
Carol, after the years of the four kids at the kitchen table sans parents, we graduated, I guess, to t.v. trays in the family room. I have no recollection what was watched. Now in my own home we have a t.v., but it is a 13 inch screen portable that disappears for the whole week only to emerge on Friday afternoons. And never, ever during dinner.
Just so you don’t have to be embarrassed alone!
Monday, May 7, 2007 – 10:34 AM
bam2 (5th of 5, aka the Caboose)
I fondly recall the tone of those big family dinners…didn’t always know what was being discussed, or rather what you were hoping to discuss, but it sure seemed lively from the 9 yr old vantage point — it was an ad man’s table, and if you couldn’t make a point in under 30 seconds, well.
Sure was different though when it was just Mom and I … I suspect that’s why we’d always tune in The McLaughlin Group after dinner on Saturdays. Lots of fast talk, everyone got cut off mid phrase, positions staked out but never really explored, the loudest voice = the last word.
Interesting point about slow cooking as a reaction to the 8.5 minute burger. I’m still seeking to duplicate Dad’s speed, at least once, in the grilling arena if no other. Kingsford had a different formulation back then and could have burned hotter; the industrial food complex was less industrial — no doubt it was safer to eat those purplish burgers. Still can’t figure the need for a plate holder.
Monday, May 7, 2007 – 11:10 AM
Carol
I hope the MOM of the brood at BAM’s childhood table weighs in with her view of dinner at 707 in the 1960s and 1970s!
Tuesday, May 8, 2007 – 03:15 AM